SD “Riot Boosting” Act Blocked in Preliminary Injunction — What this means and what’s next

Sarah Sunshine Manning · October 1, 2019

SD “Riot Boosting” Act Blocked in Preliminary Injunction — What this means and what’s next

This illegal law was a bump in the road in our fight to protect Mother Earth, but we are glad to hear that a federal judge agrees that we should have the right to organize and protest unencumbered. This is a step in the right direction.

Photo courtesy Indigene Studios.

Background

After the historic resistance against the Dakota Access pipeline in Standing Rock, the State of South Dakota, in anticipation of another wave of protests in opposition to the Keystone XL pipeline, passed the “Riot Boosting Act.”  This act was passed in the final few days of the 2019 legislative session after meetings occurred between South Dakota governor Kristi Noem and representatives from TransCanada, a Canadian energy corporation responsible for extracting and transporting oil from the Alberta Tar Sands via the Keystone XL pipeline, across several Indigenous territories in the U.S. and Canada, ultimately to be transported to the Gulf of Mexico. 

Once passed, the “Riot Boosting Act” immediately functioned to threaten activists who encourage or organize protests, particularly protests of the Keystone XL pipeline, with fines, civil liabilities, and/or criminal penalties of up to 25 years in prison.  

According to the vague language of the “Riot Boosting Act,” an individual making donations to protests could be charged with “riot boosting.”  Individuals making social media posts in support of pipeline protests could be charged similarly. Holding a “#NoKXL” protest sign could also potentially land you in court with “riot boosting” charges under this law. 

This law directly impacted the work of the NDN Collective as an organization both organizing on the ground against KXL as well as resourcing the movement to do this work.

Under the “Riot Boosting” act, the State of South Dakota and Republican Governor Kristi Noem were willing to violate the U.S. Constitution so long as it meant stopping Indigenous water protectors, land defenders and everyday common people from protecting South Dakota land from oil infrastructure development. 

Watch: NDN Collective Sues South Dakota for State Laws Protecting Pipelines

In response to what was a clear constitutional violation of free speech, the American Civil Liberties Union and the ACLU of South Dakota filed a lawsuit against the State of South Dakota and Governor Kristi Noem on behalf of plaintiffs including the NDN Collective, the Indigenous Environmental Network, Dakota Rural Action, the Sierra Club, and two individuals, Nick Tilsen with NDN Collective and Dallas Goldtooth with Indigenous Environmental Network.

Judge Piersol presided over the first hearing on the case on June 12 in Rapid City, South Dakota. A few months later on September 18, Piersol delivered his decision, issuing a preliminary injunction in favor of the plaintiffs. The injunction temporarily blocks a majority of the unconstitutional provisions of the “Riot Boosting” act; however, the lawsuit against the State of South Dakota and Governor Kristi Noem continues to be active until a final decision is delivered.

Photo courtesy Indigene Studios.

What This Injunction Means

After reviewing the “Riot Boosting” act, Judge Piersol agreed with plaintiffs that the language of “riot boosting” was too vague and it had a “chilling effect” on free speech.  Piersol also reviewed existing riot laws in the state, one enacted in 1939, which, in part, was also determined to be overbroad. 

Judge Piersol granted the preliminary injunction sought by plaintiffs, which puts a temporary hold on a majority, but not all parts of the ”Riot Boosting” act.   In his analysis, Piersol used a historical comparison in his scrutiny of the statute, “Imagine that if these riot boosting statutes were applied to the protests that took place in Birmingham, Alabama, what might be the result? … Dr. King and the Southern Christian Leadership Conference could have been liable under an identical riot boosting law.”

The South Dakota State Legislature can respond to this injunction in one of a few ways: 1) They can repeal the “Riot Boosting” act entirely; 2) They can replace the act with a new, better law that does not infringe upon our First Amendment rights to peacefully protest; or 3) The SD State Legislature can replace the act with something worse. 

The State can also appeal the preliminary injunction, and in this case, the appeal would go to the 8th Circuit Court of Appeals. 

Photo courtesy Indigene Studios.

What’s Next

While plaintiffs await next steps, the legal process continues until a final decision is reached. A preconference hearing is expected in the next few months. 

In the meantime, the NDN Collective remains optimistic. 

“The State of South Dakota and TransCanada rushed the creation of this anti-protest law in an attempt to muzzle our voices and make it difficult for us to organize against the KXL pipeline,” says Nick Tilsen, NDN Collective President and CEO. “They thought they were just going to come here and build this pipeline through the heart of Lakota territory, trample peoples’ rights and discourage our movement to protect Mother Earth– They were wrong. We are here to stay and stand up for the Earth, against destruction and injustice.”

In a time of climate crisis and ongoing devastation of Indigenous lands and territories, NDN Collective is among the scores of committed Indigenous people, water protectors, organizers, environmental rights activists, and everyday common people who remain devoted to protecting our Mother Earth while creating sustainable solutions for our future. 

“We are in a global battle to fight climate change, and shutting down the fossil fuel industry is imperative for the survival of humanity and all living things,” says Tilsen. “This illegal law was a bump in the road in our fight to protect Mother Earth, but we are glad to hear that a federal judge agrees that we should have the right to organize and protest unencumbered. This is a step in the right direction.”

STAND WITH US

Donate To Support NDN’S ONGOING LEGAL BATTLE WITH THE STATE OF SOUTH DAKOTA

NDN Collective is a 501(c)3 tax-deductible organization.

Sarah Sunshine Manning
by   Sarah Sunshine Manning

Sarah Sunshine Manning, NDN Collective Director of Communications, is a citizen of the Shoshone-Paiute Tribes of the Duck Valley Indian Reservation in Idaho and Nevada, and Chippewa-Cree of Rocky Boy, Montana. Manning directs NDN Collective’s communications strategy and impact. She also serves as producer of the NDN Podcast While Indigenous and as editor of the NDN blog. Manning has Bachelor’s degrees in American Indian Studies, Social Science-History, and licensure in Secondary Education. She has a Master’s degree in journalism and mass communication.

January 2023 Edition

Stay Informed. Take Action.

Subscribe to the NDN allies newsletter

Sign up to get our newsletter. Delivered once per month.

We care about the protection of your data and would never sell your email or share it with anyone without your permission.

Doubling Down for LANDBACK: Q & A with Nick Tilsen After 2.5 Year Legal Battle Comes to an End Posted 1 month ago
In this Q & A interview, Nick shares some of his reflections and big picture takeaways from the past two and a half years. Nick faced up to 17 years behind bars after a #LANDBACK protest in the Black Hills on July 3, 2020.
NDN Collective Announces Community Action Fund Grant Partners Posted 2 months ago
“NDN Collective is honored to invest in the self-determination and leadership of these organizations, collectives, organizers, and cultural practitioners. They are on the frontlines defending our communities from resource extraction, combating the polluters fueling climate change, and standing up for the human rights of Indigenous peoples."
NDN Collective Shares Program Intention of Collective Abundance Fund Ahead of Official Launch Posted 2 months ago
“While this financial commitment is unprecedented and significant, funding alone won’t solve the racial equity gap. Movement building must continue. Policy and advocacy work must continue to disrupt, dismantle, and shift the economic systems that don’t work for us. We can all play a part in that.”
All Charges Dismissed Against Nick Tilsen in 2.5 Year Long Case Posted 2 months ago
“My case held a mirror up to the so-called legal system, where prosecutors – fueled by white fragility and fear of Indigenous power – wasted years of state resources to intimidate, criminalize, and violate me. The fact that I’ve gone from facing 17 years in prison to all charges dismissed is not a coincidence or an act of justice – it’s evidence that the charges were bogus from the start."
NDN Collective Announces 2022 Community Self-Determination Grantee Partners Posted 2 months ago
“This cohort of grantee partners represents some of the most impactful work happening across Turtle Island—defending the air, land and water; developing Indigenous economies based on regenerative principles; and revitalizing our languages, cultures and ceremonies in ways that illuminate the path for the next generations.”
NDN Collective & Rewiring America Release IRA Memo for Tribes & Indigenous Communities Posted 2 months ago
Households could save $140,000 on energy bills over 25 years with efficient energy infrastructure – which would both help build Indigenous wealth, and help families divest from the volatile oil and gas markets. 
NDN Collective Statement on COP27 Negotiation Outcomes Posted 2 months ago
"We call on nation states to sever their relationships to the fossil fuels industry, fully commit to phasing out of fossil fuels, and utilize the core tenets of a Just Transition. Anything less is a failure to all of humanity.”
NDN Collective Responds to Mass Shooting of 2SLGBTQIA+ Relatives in Colorado Springs Posted 2 months ago
"As 2 spirit and queer individuals we long for spaces that are safe. We long for spaces that we can show up in and be our unapologetic queer selves without the fear of persecution. What happened to our relatives in Colorado is a violation of that sacred space and only triggers a more profound hyper vigilance of our spaces, our communities and of ourselves."
COP27: NDN Collective's Recap of Week One at the United Nations 27th Annual Conference of the Parties (COP) in Sharm El Sheikh, Egypt Posted 3 months ago
"Our delegation has been participating in the Indigenous Peoples Caucus and the Local Communities Indigenous Peoples Platform, as well as tracking negotiations, meeting with government officials, and more."
COP27: NDN Collective Meets with White House Climate Advisor Posted 3 months ago
In their discussion with White House Climate Advisor Ali Zaidi, NDN Collective, alongside frontline Indigenous and Black organizers touched on issue areas including IRA, mining, oil and gas leases.

United like never before, we rise together—arm in arm—to equip all Indigenous Peoples with the tools needed to become architects of our future. Through a holistic approach to infrastructure, funding, advocacy, movement building, and philanthropy we are fostering a world of justice and equity for all people and the planet.