Nick Tilsen’s Evidentiary Hearing Result: Judge Takes Defense Under Advisement

October 28, 2021

Nick Tilsen’s Evidentiary Hearing Result: Judge Takes Defense Under Advisement

Pennington County State Prosecutor Mark Vargo takes the stand to defend his conduct. Judge takes decision under advisement.

Nick Tilsen addresses the crowd before the evidentiary hearing on Wednesday.

For immediate Release: October 28, 2021

Rapid City, SD — On Wednesday, October 27, the judge for Nick Tilsen’s evidentiary hearing took his legal team’s request for discovery items and motions filed against the Pennington County State’s Attorney’s Office to dismiss Tilsen’s case– which cited prosecutorial misconduct and violations of his rights to a speedy trial and free speech– under advisement. The judge said a decision will be delivered in a timely manner, which Tilsen interprets as within a week or two.

In Response, NDN Collective President and CEO Nick Tilsen shared the following statement:

“In today’s evidentiary hearing, we were able to give arguments supporting our motion to dismiss all of my charges on the basis of vindictive persecution, prosecutorial misconduct, and denying my right to a speedy trial and my right to freedom of speech. We had the opportunity to put Mark Vargo of the Pennington County Prosecutor’s Office on the stand, and he had to answer for his conduct in this process. It is our hope that if the judge sees any merit in Vargo’s mistreatment of my case, that all of my charges would be dismissed. 

The judge also acknowledged today that the Pennington County Prosecutor’s Office and Pennington County Jail are actually recipients of a grant from the McArthur Foundation for the purpose of reducing the over incarceration of Native people. Vargo is the co-chair of that work, and yet I’m being overly prosecuted as a Native man by Vargo, facing 17 years in prison. The injustice here is clear, and my case is just one of many where Native people are vindictively persecuted for being who we are. 

Photo by Willi White for NDN Collective.


“Regardless of what the judge decides after taking the decision under advisement, a magnifying glass was put on the system today. White supremacy was put on trial, and racism was put on trial. And when these unjust systems put us on trial, at NDN Collective and as Indigenous people, we are going to stand up and speak truth to power. 

Today while in the courtroom, my heart and mind was also with all our Native people in the so-called justice system, who don’t have the same access to legal support or resources, who don’t have lawyers or other people to stand up for them and fight for them. While this was heavy on my mind and my heart, it is also fuel to keep fighting this system that impacts and harms our lives as Indigenous people. This is a fight for our land, for the Black Hills and for our people. We have no choice but to keep standing up and rising up.” 

###

Timeline of Nick Tilsen’s Case:

NDN Collective is an Indigenous-led organization dedicated to building Indigenous power. Through organizing, activism, philanthropy, grantmaking, capacity-building, and narrative change, we are creating sustainable solutions on Indigenous terms.

April 2023 Edition

Stay Informed. Take Action.

Subscribe to the NDN allies newsletter

Sign up to get our newsletter. Delivered once per month.

We care about the protection of your data and would never sell your email or share it with anyone without your permission.

Meet the 2023/24 Cohort of NDN Changemaker Fellows Posted 2 days ago
Learn more about these phenomenal visionaries who continue to enact revolutionary change and build Indigenous power.
NDN Collective Urges POTUS to Reject “Permitting Reform” in Debt Ceiling Posted 1 week ago
“We are being shut out as environmental and climate related policy is part of the debt ceiling negotiations.”
5 things Indian Country Needs to Know about the Dirty Permitting Deal Posted 1 week ago
It is critical in the coming days and weeks that we mobilize and tell President Biden to reject the #DirtyDeal & #DefaultOnAmerica Act!
NDN Collective announces 2023/24 NDN Changemaker Fellow Cohort Posted 2 weeks ago
"We are hosting visionaries from their early twenties into their elder years, each one offering strong work, new perspectives, and pathways towards a future that speaks to the question our founder and CEO Nick Tilsen poses, “What if our best days are ahead of us?”
NDN Collective Launches 2023 Collective Abundance Grant: A Wealth Building Opportunity for Indigenous Families Posted 3 weeks ago
The Collective Abundance Fund supports the traditional aspects of wealth, like down payments on a home, education expenses, or capital investments in a new or current business.
NDN Collective and Native Organizers Alliance Respond to Biden 2024 Re-election Announcement Posted 1 month ago
“Now more than ever, it is crucial for the Biden-Harris administration to recognize the leadership of Native peoples and our communities’ ability to drive turnout in local and federal elections. The Native vote holds the power to determine the outcome of elections. We cannot be ignored.”
NDN Collective Launches Podcast, "LANDBACK for the People" Posted 1 month ago
Featuring conversations with Indigenous organizers, activists, matriarchs, and protectors from across Turtle Island, LANDBACK For the People provides an up-close-and-personal experience that is bold, action-oriented, and solution-focused. The first episode features Civil rights pioneer Madonna Thunder Hawk.
NDN Collective Responds to Biden Climate Justice Executive Order Posted 1 month ago
"This action from the Biden Administration signals that our guidance and feedback, informed by our lived experience as environmental justice and Tribal community members, is not only being heard but is being acted upon and implemented in the ways that we need."
NDN Collective Welcomes the Collective Abundance Team Posted 1 month ago
The team of three will support the implementation of the Collective Abundance Fund, which is to support the rebuilding of Indigenous and generational wealth by providing significant resources for wealth building activities across the tri-state region of Minnesota, North Dakota, and South Dakota.
NDN Collective Announces 2023 Open Application Period for "Community Action Fund" in Support of Indigenous Frontline Organizers Posted 1 month ago
Grants up to $30,000 offered to support on the ground organizers and movement builders who stand on the frontlines to defend Indigenous Peoples inherent rights to self-determination and equity for all people and Mother Earth.

United like never before, we rise together—arm in arm—to equip all Indigenous Peoples with the tools needed to become architects of our future. Through a holistic approach to infrastructure, funding, advocacy, movement building, and philanthropy we are fostering a world of justice and equity for all people and the planet.