Dr. Gabriela Spears-Rico · February 10, 2019

In Gratitude of All Yalitza Gives us Within the Limitations of Roma

I know what it’s like to grow up indigenous in a country and culture that does not embrace my features or skin-color. Coming of age in Michoacán and California, I was called names like ‘indita,’ ‘charilla’ and ‘oaxaquita’ – diminutive slurs meant to infantilize and demean indigenous people. As an anthropologist conducting fieldwork in Mexico,… Continued

I know what it’s like to grow up indigenous in a country and culture that does not embrace my features or skin-color. Coming of age in Michoacán and California, I was called names like ‘indita,’ ‘charilla’ and ‘oaxaquita’ – diminutive slurs meant to infantilize and demean indigenous people. As an anthropologist conducting fieldwork in Mexico, I have been escorted off hotel steps and denied bathroom access in restaurants I was patronizing due to my phenotype, skin-color and choice to wear indigenous clothing.

My experience is not atypical and my migrant experience and class privilege allows me to move in and out of mestizaje in a way that those who reside in indigenous communities cannot. Mexican anthropologists and historians have written about Mexico’s long contradictory relationship with indigenous people: the tendency to revere dead Indians as contributors to the magnificence of ‘the cosmic race’ while completely ignoring the humanity of today’s indigenous communities.

Considering indigenous people poor, dumb and ugly are a result of Mexico’s elevation of light-skinned mestizaje as the racial ideal and symptomatic of our homeland’s long love-affair with Europhilia. This is why, along with other indigenous Mexicans, I have been applauding Yalitza Aparicio’s visibility while remaining critical of how and whether her performance and visibility in Alfonso Cuarón’s “Roma” empowers indigenous people. 

Yalitza Aparicio with family. Courtesy of Facebook.

When I learned of the film’s focus on an indigenous service worker, I expected to encounter the same narrative of indigeneity that production companies like Televisa have banked on since the 60s. As a girl-child consuming Mexican media in telenovelas in the 1980s, I thought of myself as ugly and came to hate my indigenous features. Indigenous women and Black women in telenovelas were uneducated, ignorant, poor service workers who would often be physically or verbally abused by the light-skinned mestiza/o leads. Roma gave us a more nuanced representation of indigeneity.

As an indigenous viewer, I experienced Roma as visually gripping. The breathtaking black and white cinematography, deliberate pacing of the mundane, and the focus on Yalitza’s face and body ruptured the viewers’ sense of temporality. Where could we place this striking Mixtec woman who demanded attention and power despite the narrative’s focus on her domestic tasks? With the camera deliberately following Cleo’s movements as she moved through her routine and the intentional pauses on Yalitza’s face, her forehead, her eyes, her mouth and nose, Cuarón succeeded in centering Cleo’s perspective in the film and in defying the Hollywood formula of objectifying or exotifying indigenous women. 

Considering indigenous people poor, dumb and ugly are a result of Mexico’s elevation of light-skinned mestizaje as the racial ideal and symptomatic of our homeland’s long love-affair with Europhilia.

Cleo’s routinized embodied labor guide the storyline. We not only “see” Cleo’s body take up space in every room of the house but we also see the conflicts that unfold for the mestiza/o family through Cleo’s perspective. Through Cleo’s eyes, we witness their vulnerabilities from the impending divorce and how much Sra. Sofia, in particular, relies on Cleo for the daily operation of the home. We also see Cleo’s compassion, particularly for the children, as they become more vulnerable and fragile in the situation. These filmic and narrative elements show that Cuarón stepped out of Hollywood and the Spanish-speaking media’s formula when portraying an indigenous maid. The film, however, is still full of upper middle-class mestizo nostalgia for a romanticized past tied to Cuarón’s childhood experiences with an indigenous service-worker. This is displayed in several denials of Cleo’s humanity that triggered my wounds as an indigenous viewer.

Photograph by Carlos Somonte

Despite the central portrayals of Cleo in the house, she is never fully humanized. We don’t learn much about her past, about her family, community or her ethnic group. In one instance, Adela asks Cleo if she knows that her mother has been evicted from her lands. This signals to a land struggle in Cleo’s Mixtec community. To this, Cleo responds that she is unable to help her Mom, which tells us of indigenous people’s powerlessness in land encroachment situations in Latin America well into the 1970s. This is the only specific mention, however, that signals who Cleo is as an autonomous indigenous person and how her family experiences indigeneity. The story-line, instead, moves by events that impact the mestizo family in Mexico City such as the student massacre in El Halconazo. While this choice fits the film’s setting in Mexico City, it leaves audiences wondering who Cleo and her people are as human beings. What are her own desires and dreams away from this family if she could have them?

Additionally, there are moments of deeply hurtful anti-indigenous misogynist violence that are left unaddressed both by the filmmaker and by Cleo’s character. When she is having problems with her husband, Sra. Sofia berates Cleo in a very infantilizing way, asking her, “How many times did I ask you to clean up the dog shit?!” The scene then cuts to Cleo cleaning up the dog shit. Here, Cleo is literally reduced to dog shit; she is berated by the mestiza matriarch and punished without being able to defend herself or receiving an apology. 

Photograph by Carlos Somonte

A similar scene unfolds when Cleo visits Fermin, her meager mestizo boyfriend, to inform him about her pregnancy. Fermin responds by threatening to beat Cleo and her unborn baby to death. This is a particularly misogynist moment of anti-indigenous violence that is extremely triggering and left unattended to. While I understand Cuarón’s intentions to perhaps show the reality of mestizo racism and the violence of Mexican patriarchy, I would have liked for Cleo to have been given some space in the film to process and grieve. The movie goes on after this without showing Cleo’s emotional engagement with Fermin’s abandonment and threat. Throughout the film, Cleo is portrayed as stoic and strong and able to move on quickly after sustaining emotional abuse and racism.

Indigenous people have feelings and we show them and we have embodied responses to threats, ridicule and loss. It’s appropriate to show our vulnerabilities in film alongside our strength; it makes us human.

Cleo’s humanity is also denied by the mestizo family. The family is portrayed as innocent, good sponsors but they actually commit violence that reaches beyond the verbal abuse of their service workers. When she drives Cleo to the hospital to give birth, Sra. Teresa reveals that she does not know anything about Cleo beyond her name. She doesn’t know Cleo’s date of birth or birthplace and bursts out, “No, no, I don’t know anything!” It is apparent here that this family takes little interest in knowing who Cleo is beyond her servile role in their home.

Indigenous people have feelings and we show them and we have embodied responses to threats, ridicule and loss. It’s appropriate to show our vulnerabilities in film alongside our strength; it makes us human. 

Additionally, it is extremely difficult to watch Cleo deliver her stillborn baby completely alone. We do not hear or see Cleo grieve until the film’s closing during an emotional incident when she literally saves Sra. Sofia’s -the mestiza mother’s- children from drowning. She finally cries and utters how terrible and guilty she feels that she lost her own daughter. To this, Sra. Sofia responds, “We love you, Cleo. We love you very much.” Sra. Sofia’s sincere recognition of Cleo’s suffering provides comfort but does not allow the viewer to focus on Cleo’s emotions and healing from trauma.

Despite its limits, Roma has broken new ground in promoting indigenous beauty, visibility and representation. Cuarón was recently quoted as saying that Aparicio could play any role she wants, giving her credit for carrying Roma and the cast into the success the film has had. He was partly responding to the virulent racism that Mexican people and Mexican critics have launched at Aparacio in print, television and social media. People have said that there is nothing special about her beauty (that she looks like many other Mexican women) and that her visibility is a result of tokenizing an indigenous person in Mexico rather than something that should be attributed to her talent.

Yalitza Aparicio with pre-school students.
Photo Courtesy of Facebook.

It is apparent that Yalitza Aparicio has had a powerful and beautiful presence before her stardom; a photo of her in her role as a pre-K teacher was released by Mexican media outlets last month. Donning a bright-colored long traditional dress alongside her young pupils, she commands attention and takes up the photo’s central space. It is apparent from her pre-Roma photos that this woman was born to stand out. For Mexicans to think otherwise is ridiculous and racist. 

Yalitza Aparicio officially became the first indigenous woman to ever be nominated for an Oscar. Along with my Mexican indigenous female colleagues and friends, I have been savoring this moment of female indigenous visibility. Every image released of Aparicio on the red carpet or on the cover of a major magazine is a reminder that we are worthy and beautiful – both worth looking at and worthy of having our talents recognized. I am not completely cheeky on Roma but I will be rooting for Yalitza this Oscar season. I anxiously await to see her on the Oscars red-carpet and I hope she gets to play many different roles in the future.

Dr. Gabriela Spears-Rico
by   Dr. Gabriela Spears-Rico

Dr. Gabriela Spears-Rico is an interdisciplinary cultural anthropologist with roots in the Matlatzinca community of Charo, Michoacán. She is an Assistant Professor of American Indian Studies and Chicano Latino Studies at the University of Minnesota Twin Cities and can be reached at [email protected]

August 2022 Edition

Stay Informed. Take Action.

Subscribe to the NDN allies newsletter

Sign up to get our newsletter. Delivered once per month.

We care about the protection of your data and would never sell your email or share it with anyone without your permission.

NDN Collective Responds to Manchin's Side Deal Being Pulled from IRA Posted 1 week ago
“Make no mistake – the decoupling of Manchin’s dirty side deal from the Inflation Reduction Act is a result of tireless advocacy by frontline, climate justice, and Indigenous communities."
NDN Collective Hosts Extreme Heat and Climate Change Webinar

Brandi Douglas

Posted 2 weeks ago
The webinar included a presentation by Dr. Gaurab Basu, of Cambridge Health Alliance, in collaboration with the NDN Collective Climate Justice Team, providing information needed to prepare and adapt to the heat and climate change health equity crisis.
Impacts of Permitting Reform Proposal on Tribes and Indigenous Communities

NDN Collective Climate Justice Team , Dr. Kyle Whyte

Posted 2 weeks ago
This analysis and summary, co-authored by the NDN Collective Climate Justice Team alongside Dr. Kyle Whyte, organizer and Professor of Environment and Sustainability at the University of Michigan, captures the impacts of Sen. Joe Manchin’s (D-WV) permitting reform proposal and is based on the most recent draft text released on September 21, 2022. 
NDN Collective Announces Open Application Period for NDN Changemaker Fellowship Posted 2 weeks ago
“We are honored to offer this fellowship and recognize visionary Indigenous changemakers who are working towards defending their territories, sustainably developing and decolonizing their communities.” 
Honoring Youth and Families: NDN Collective 3rd Annual Backpack Giveaway Provides More Than School Supplies

Brandi Douglas

Posted 3 weeks ago
“Our hope is that this event starts the kids' school year off in a good way and shows them we recognize, value and honor them.”
NDN Collective Officially Opens Doors of Rapid City's First Indigenous-Led School for Indigenous Students Posted 4 weeks ago
"It is important for students to see themselves in what they are learning everyday, and to have the opportunity to be who they are, learn their language, and be recognized for their inherent Indigenous genius. At Oceti Sakowin Community Academy students will have the opportunity to do this, which is what the ancestors have wanted for our wakanyeja – our children.”
Indigenous Groups From North America Write Letter to Chilean Leadership, Supporting Monumental Provisions in Proposed Chilean Constitution Posted 4 weeks ago
"Chile’s newly proposed constitution sets a precedent for the U.S. and other governments to not only recognize it is beyond time to update our draconian constitutions, but also that integrating Indigenous rights into our core laws will move us towards truly achieving equity and justice."
Sko Vote Den Artist Showcase Brings Music and Voter Engagement to Santa Fe

Brandy Calabaza

Posted 1 month ago
Bringing Indigenous relatives together through art and music for a fun and interactive event aimed at the power of voting, encouraging attendees to utilize their ability to vote in the upcoming election as a means of building and reclaiming Indigenous power.
NDN Collective Takes One Step Closer to Building Tiny Home Community for Houseless Relatives in Rapid City

Brandi Douglas

Posted 1 month ago
NDN Collective’s tiny home community development, Gliúŋ, to provide essential needs, access to resources, security and belonging to unhoused Indigenous relatives in the Rapid City area.
NDN Collective to Co-Host ‘Sko Vote Den Artist Showcase’ in Santa Fe Posted 2 months ago
“Indigenous people have been shut out of the political sphere for far too long – it’s time to show up for ourselves and our communities, by centering our issues, our solutions, and electing our people to office.”

United like never before, we rise together—arm in arm—to equip all Indigenous Peoples with the tools needed to become architects of our future. Through a holistic approach to infrastructure, funding, advocacy, movement building, and philanthropy we are fostering a world of justice and equity for all people and the planet.